Skip to main content

Whose Labyrinthine Maze is This, Anyway: Dungeon Design and Cultural History

Dungeon. The word with significant historical connotations and some modern ones we won’t get into here, but to enthusiasts of tabletop roleplaying, it means something very specific: it’s ⅓ of the name of the most successful and influential RPG of all time, after all. (We’ll discuss the significance of the “&” another time. (and maybe the other D too - A) ) Early D&D materials refer to “the underworld mazes” (note the preposition, dungeons are considered a default part of the setting), and offer some advice on making them (somewhat) plausible, but never directly consider the societies that built them. While many pre-published adventures do include some information describing long-gone inhabitants, incorporating this kind of detail into original worlds can help create a detailed, rich setting. This week, we thought we’d talk about how to make dungeons and other ruins feel like places that lost peoples made and lived in, and how to share these details in your play sessions. - B 

A: Before you can bring any of these locations into your game, you must answer the questions of "who" and "why". Who was it that built and inhabited the location of your next adventure? Was it some old wizard from a millennium ago? If so, what kind of wizard were they? An evil lich slain long ago brings to mind different thoughts than some crazed arcane experimenter or a noble protector of the realm. It may have been created by an old lost monarch. You might have the same thoughts here, what kind of a ruler were they? This will inform not only what kinds of rooms may be in your locations, but the kinds of descriptions and objects your players will find in these places. You might also consider why it became abandoned. Plague? Large scale battle? Natural Disaster? Any of these different scenarios can help you alter your descriptions for these places. They may also inform you how the surrounding landscape has changed. A farming village with a manor house hit by a plague may have wild overgrown plants, possibly even with plant based creatures having developed. The descriptions of Thundertree in Lost Mine of Phandelver are a great example of this.

Another thing to consider in the “who” and “why” categories would be the time period between when the pace was abandoned and when your adventuring party is visiting. Did goblins live in a village for a while and befoul the place? Did giant birds start roosting in the remains of an old starship where everyone was turned to stone? You can easily see how both of these scenarios change the way you would describe the dilapidated ruins to your characters. It might even be just as interesting if the ruins aren’t dilapidated. If they aren’t, what kept them from going to spoil? Who did it and why? Even with pre-written adventures, taking some of these questions under consideration can drastically change how you present the story. If we've answered some of these questions for ourselves, we can move on to actually playing around in these locales. Bugsy, how do you go about presenting these “dungeons” to the players at your table once you’ve decided a little something about their histories?

B: Like most of D&D's first incarnation, dungeons were "borrowed" from Gary Gygax's favorite fantasy series, Conan the Barbarian. (Not do downplay influence of mythology on both creators, or course.) But, given how much closer D&D was to a wargame at that point, they didn't borrow the complex histories Robert Howard gave Hyboria. Dungeons were designed around the challenge they present to the players, and it was only later editions that expanded their nature.. slightly. Not to say that a design shouldn't be based around the scenarios you want to run and the difficulty curve you want to offer your players, quite the opposite - play and interaction should always come first. The trick to share detail that inform and establish that play.

As Andy said, the "who" and "why" are central, here. Let's start with the second. Was this somewhere people lived, where complexity grew organically with changes in population, technology, and resource availability? You'll want to convey that, regardless of their current condition, the various routes were made for travel, and that different places had specific (if possibly shifting) purposes. The town square may have once been a marketplace or arena, or maybe served as a makeshift hospital in times of plague. It's important to remember, though, that, with the exception of immediate catastrophes like the destruction of Pompeii, cities and towns aren't abandoned all at once, and tend to suffer gradual decay as the population dwindles. As such, if you want to convey an abandoned city while still presenting the players navigational complexities, you can incorporate collapsed buildings, blocked streets, and other obstacles on top of what may already be an obtuse layout. Clues indicating the city's fate can be scattered among the debris, such as valuable artifacts found in close, tight, tenements, which might indicate the wealthy fled quickly, leaving their finery behind to be looted, or that their districts became uninhabitable for some reason, and they forced the poor from the city to take their housing. You don't need to provide the full story, but details like this can get the players speculating about what happened, and thus more involved in the setting.

If the PCs are going somewhere beneath a city (whether abandoned or still-inhabited), such as sewers, remember that these still tend to follow the basic layout of roads and housing as the land above ground... or, at least, how it was when the underground structure was built. There's a reason, after all, that the "underground tunnels of the Old City" is a classic trope, offering the discovery and exploration of an abandoned place in proximity to a modern space. In any case, if you're looking a quick way to layout a cityscape, there's certainly nothing wrong with stealing from history. One great source for historic maps is Old Maps Online, a searchable database of maps owned by museums and schools. Naturally, this is an even better tool for those running historic games in real-world settings.

Of course, many dungeons are places that had never been meant for occupation: temples, catacombs, necropolises. Many of these have been inspired by (usually quite apocryphal) pulp stories in the height of the Egyptology craze, but the same considerations apply: who built it, and why did they do it the way they did? It's easy to make the assumption that a particular layout was created to befuddle (and/or trap and kill) graverobbers, but balance this out with the time and effort it would take to actually build such a design. Ultimately, it's more interesting to tie things to the culture of the people who built it. If this was a temple, are there large spaces in which to consecrate services, and apartments further in that housed the priesthood? Was the place built as a rite of (literal) passage, where supplicants had to find their way through to achieve enlightenment? If this was somewhere made to house the dead, how does it reflect the builders? Was only royally interred here, or others as well? No one structure could be large enough for entire communities, so there must have been some kind of selection, how did they decide who was important enough? Finally, there are the PCs reasons for entering a once-sacred space. If (again inspired by Eygptology pulps), they're simply pillaging treasures that were left here, why did the builders choose to seal valuables away? Was it simply out of worship, or was it more a way to remove some degree of wealth from the economy, ensuring that the nobility or royalty couldn't pass too much on to their descendants?

Speaking of which, it's worth it to consider the effect on the current economy of all the treasures being plundered from long-gone civilizations. If they stay within the local market, there could become a glut of antiques that become less valuable with each haul. But if they're being exported, how does the influx of money affect the local economy? Does the processing of artifacts become the only viable activity for the locals to engage in. The manga and anime series Made in Abyss depicts a community in just such a  circumstance, where the town on the edge of the titular Abyss is focused entirely on training people to delve for artifacts, processing and exporting those artifacts, and selling provisions to any outsiders who want to try their hand at "cave raiding." In any case, you should always bear the significance of holy artifacts in mind, which might include anything found in a temple - since many of the gods in D&D exist within that universe, it's probably a bad ides to risk getting on their wrong side!

Again, none of this needs to be the adventure's focus. (Although, if something seems interesting and gives you ideas for development, it certainly can be!) But keeping these things in mind when designing a location can help to make things consistent. From the stuff the PCs stumble across to descriptions of architecture and murals, each detail should include a little bit of that place's story. Not only will this help flesh out the setting and keep the players engaged, it also reminds them that they are only a small part of a larger world: one of  glories and tragedies, of peoples present and long-gone, of stories concurrent and enshrined in legend. As for whether they, too, will become part of that legend... that's for those at the table to decide. 

Send comments and questions to or Tweet them @neversaydice2.


Popular posts from this blog

The Matt Mercer Effect

Roleplaying games have been around for quite a long time even before the first edition of  Dungeons & Dragons was published in 1974. You can go back into the history of Commedia dell’arte (improvisational theatre) in 16th century Europe and see this form of storytelling (and, if you want to read about similar, but more recent, traditions, take a look at our posts on the Maryland Renaissance Festival .) Even before that, there were ancient historical re-enactments and storytelling in many different cultures. Modern tabletop roleplaying games are quite different, even from their 1974 form, but commonality is shared across all these. After all, we’re still just playing playground games with the assistance of rules and dice. In recent years, there's been a boom in roleplaying games due to a number of factors: The internet making it easier to find new players and even run play sessions online. General dissatisfaction with our own realities, shared or personal. One force driving th

Star Trek v. Star Trek: The Starship Enterprise's Fifty-Year Confusion

The question "what was your first Star Trek" carries a very different weight today than it did thirty-five years ago. All the classic (i.e., pre- Discovery ) series are instantly available across multiple streaming services, and the films aren't much harder to find - they were some of the first shows to be made available via streaming, in fact. And even before then, there were both broadcast and cable reruns, along with physical copies for sale and rental. For today's viewers, the question usually means "which show or movie is the one that 'clicked' for you, that made you want more?" And, from there, we can deduce what they like about the franchise - stylistically, thematically, and tonally, since Star Trek can be a lot of things for a a lot of people. But it wasn't always this way. For a while, Star Trek was only available sporadically. Even while the movies were doing well at the box office, prospective viewers were at the mercy of whoever mad

The Mission Will Be Very Safe and Fun for Everyone: Some Thoughtcrimes on Running Paranoia

  I'm sorry citizen, but the question "why hasn't there been a Paranoia post in over fifteen months" cannot be processed. Records indicate that the previous post, " [Backstory Redacted] - Getting Ready to Run Paranoia " was activated in the Year 214 of the Computer, and, as this is currently Year 214 of the Computer, your internal chronometer must be malfunctioning. Rumors that is has always been Year 214 of the Computer are treason. Please report to Internal Security for cerebral re-adjustment. Have a nice daycycle. So, why hasn't there been a post about Paranoia in fifteen months, anyway? The previous two have been quite popular , and, as I'm fond of saying, I've put more thought into this game than nearly anything else in my life, formal education included. As time went on, I found myself procrastinating on the follow-up. I didn't have enough time to work out everything I'd want to cover, I'd tell myself, or that some other top

Fun With Murder: The Narrative Ethics of Assassination Games

It's funny. As someone who views "detective" as an integral part of their personality , I sure have a lot of crime games. Well, crime media in general, especially movies, but games have certain... implications. You're the one committing the crimes , not watching other characters do them or following a protagonist as they piece together criminal events through evidence and investigation. You're right there, doing all the bad stuff yourself. Recently, in the ongoing quest to tackle my massive game backlog, I've been playing the first Tenchu game, released in 1998. I bought it because the creators would later go on to make my beloved Way of the Samurai series, but if one looked at my shelves, they could easily assume I chose it thematically, as Tenchu 's neighbors include numerous Hitman , Assassin's Creed , and Dishonored games - a subgenre we'll call "assassination games." I've seen it remarked that there's an irony that, while